Jungwirth, M., Glukhodid, N., ”Returning to the Past? Typology of Decision-Making of Ukrainian Refugees in the Czech Republic and Germany,” in Fragmented Lives: Uncertainties of War Displacement within and from Ukraine, ed. Lidia Kuzemska (Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, 2025).
Unequal Sacrifice, Emerging Divisions:
Wartime Contribution and National Belonging
Wars reshape not only the boundaries of the states but also the boundaries of the nations that fight them. I examine one such redrawing of the nation’s social map, asking whether and how wartime contribution becomes a central criterion, above others, for judging national belonging and leadership legitimacy in a country at war. Whereas existing research treats wartime sacrifice as a basis for claims on the state, I focus on horizontal judgments, which show how war redraws lines of inclusion and exclusion among citizens themselves. I argue that wars of national defense bring two logics of boundary-making into tension: ascriptive, grounded in inherited markers, and contributive, grounded in demonstrated wartime behavior. Drawing on extensive fieldwork coupled with ethnographic observations (87 semi-structured interviews) and a preregistered conjoint experiment in wartime Ukraine (n = 1,365), I find that wartime contribution is the strongest basis on which respondents evaluate their compatriots, an effect roughly twice as large as the penalties for Russian ancestry and language. Yet contributing does not reduce the penalty attached to Russian ancestry. Disaggregating contribution by type of service (military or civilian), exposure to risk (front or rear), and non-contribution by legitimacy (evasion, deferment, and non-participation) reveals the heterogeneous nature of reward or penalty. Frontline military service is rewarded most, civilian volunteering and rear military service are rewarded comparably, and evading mobilization is penalized beyond passive non-contribution. I conclude that wars of national defense can introduce a new basis of social differentiation without displacing existing ascriptive boundaries, as divisions around wartime contribution emerge alongside prewar ethnic and linguistic divides.
Concordia Discors: Impact of Wartime Violence on National Identity
Does losing members of your community in war strengthen national identity? Drawing on an original dataset of individual-level high school exam results from 2010 to 2026 and a difference-in-differences design, this paper shows that settlement-level exposure to aerial bombardment and military deaths leads students to perform comparatively better in Ukrainian language and literature than in mathematics. I introduce a novel behavioral measure of national identity and rely on fieldwork with teachers, former high school students and local education elites across Ukraine to argue for collective mourning and peer pressure as the central mechanisms at work.
Rethinking the Citizen-Soldier: Wartime Contribution and Shifting Boundaries of National Belonging
This paper develops the concept of wartime contribution and shows how citizens redraw who belongs to the nation based on who fights, serves, and sacrifices or avoids contributing to the collective war effort by evading, going abroad, or remaining passive. I use over 200 hours of in-depth fieldwork interviews and ethnographic observations across multiple locations in Germany and Ukraine to illustrate the relational and horizontal nature of wartime contribution in wartime Ukraine.
Who Counts as a Defender? Women's Wartime Contribution
How do gendered expectations of women as mothers and caregivers interact with the overall social expectation to contribute to the collective effort of national defense? In a preregistered conjoint experiment (N = 1,365), I find that women are substantially rewarded for their own wartime contribution, though less than men for comparable contributions; that motherhood is modestly rewarded, contrary to expectations in much of the literature; and that husbands' service, death in service, or draft evasion carries over to how respondents evaluate women's national belonging. I call this last effect transferred wartime contribution.
Church Property Regimes, Local Elites, and Parish Switching
This paper asks: When do changes in national sentiment translate into institutional change? Using an original national dataset of parishes leaving the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate for the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Kyiv Patriarchate, and later for the Orthodox Church of Ukraine, from 2014 to 2026, along with interviews with parishioners, priests, and religion experts, I show that grassroots mobilization alone is rarely enough. Whether a parish switches depends on who controls church property, where the local priest stands, and local politics.